How period tracking apps and data privacy fit into a post-Roe v. Wade climate : NPR


A pc programmer prints a code on a laptop computer keyboard.

Rapeepong Puttakumwong/Getty Photographs

disguise caption

toggle caption

Rapeepong Puttakumwong/Getty Photographs

A pc programmer prints a code on a laptop computer keyboard.

Rapeepong Puttakumwong/Getty Photographs

Within the wake of the leaked draft Supreme Courtroom opinion that might overturn Roe v. Wade, privateness specialists are more and more involved about how information collected from period-tracking apps, amongst different purposes, may doubtlessly be used to penalize anybody in search of or contemplating an abortion.

Hundreds of thousands of individuals use apps to assist observe their menstrual cycles. Flo, which payments itself as the preferred interval and cycle monitoring app, has amassed 43 million energetic customers. One other app, Clue, claims 12 million month-to-month energetic customers.

The private well being information saved in these apps is among the many most intimate forms of data an individual can share. And it can be telling. The apps can present when their interval stops and begins and when a being pregnant stops and begins.

That has privateness specialists on edge, as a result of if abortion is ever criminalized, this information — whether or not subpoenaed or bought to a 3rd get together — could possibly be used to counsel that somebody has had or is contemplating an abortion.

“We’re very involved in a variety of advocacy areas about what occurs when personal companies or the federal government can achieve entry to deeply delicate information about folks’s lives and actions,” says Lydia X. Z. Brown, a coverage counsel with the Privateness and Knowledge Mission on the Heart for Democracy and Expertise. “Particularly when that information may put folks in susceptible and marginalized communities in danger for precise hurt.”

A minimum of 26 states are “certain or likely” to ban abortions if the Supreme Courtroom overturns Roe v. Wade, in line with the Guttmacher Institute, a analysis group that helps abortion rights.

However some states have signaled an curiosity to go additional. Two days after the leaked Supreme Courtroom opinion was first reported by Politico, lawmakers in Louisiana advanced a bill that might classify abortion as a murder.

It is extra than simply interval apps

Evan Greer, director of the digital rights advocacy group Battle for the Future, says interval apps aren’t the one methods expertise can be utilized to attach somebody to an abortion. If somebody is sitting within the ready room of a clinic that provides abortion companies and is enjoying a recreation on their cellphone, that app is likely to be amassing location information, she says.

“Any app that’s amassing delicate details about your well being or your physique ought to be given a further stage of scrutiny,” Greer says.

Search histories is also figuring out, says Brown. Activist teams — no matter what they’re advocating for — would possibly attempt to buy a dataset that might present the place folks have been looking for data associated to abortion.

That data could possibly be used for predatory promoting, in line with Brown, however it may additionally supply a manner for personal residents to report one other individual for in search of an abortion. This could possibly be particularly dangerous in Texas, they added, given the state’s controversial new abortion legislation known as SB 8.

The legislation bans abortion as quickly as cardiac exercise is detectable — usually round six weeks. It additionally empowers personal residents to implement the ban by funds of at the least $10,000 for anybody who efficiently sues an abortion supplier.

“Anyone may get their fingers on this information by merely buying it from an organization that’s already amassing it,” Brown says.

Sharing information from apps is not unprecedented

It is not unusual for apps to cooperate with legislation enforcement throughout felony investigations — oftentimes round baby exploitative imagery particularly. If abortion is criminalized, specialists say period-tracking information may turn out to be a goal for investigators.

All of which makes an app’s privateness insurance policies particularly essential, however in the case of privateness, these insurance policies might be imprecise and in flux, in line with Andrea Ford, a analysis fellow on the College of Edinburgh.

“It turns into actually muddy while you get into abortion,” Ford says. “If that [were to become] unlawful in sure locations, does that transcend the fitting to privateness that’s written into the contracts in the best way that baby trafficking would?”

The Flo app has come below fireplace for sharing information earlier than.

Final yr, the Federal Commerce Fee reached a settlement with the favored fertility and period-tracking app amid allegations that it misled customers in regards to the disclosure of their private well being information. The settlement adopted a 2019 Wall Avenue Journal investigation that discovered the app knowledgeable Fb when a consumer was having their interval or in the event that they knowledgeable the app that they supposed to get pregnant.

Below the settlement, the FTC stated Flo should bear an unbiased overview of its privateness coverage and acquire consumer permissions earlier than sharing private well being data. Flo did not admit any wrongdoing as a part of the settlement.

In an announcement to NPR, the corporate stated it “firmly believes girls’s well being information ought to be held with the utmost privateness and care always, which is why we don’t share well being information with any third get together.”

The corporate added that an exterior, unbiased privateness audit accomplished in March “confirmed there are not any gaps or weaknesses in our privateness practices.”

In an announcement to NPR, period-tracking app Clue stated “any information you observe in Clue about pregnancies, being pregnant loss or abortion, is stored personal and protected.” As a European firm, the corporate stated it’s obligated to use “particular protections” to reproductive well being information, per European legislation.

Regardless of such pledges, Jason Hong, a professor at Carnegie Mellon College’s Faculty of Pc Science, cautions that the info a consumer inputs right into a period-tracking app may attain far past the cellphone or the app they’re utilizing.

“It is actually exhausting to know how your information is getting used and the place it is being shared as a result of it could possibly be many many third events, and people third events can even resell to different third events,” Hong says. “Your information may really be all around the community at this level. And it is actually exhausting to trace what is going on on.”

OK, however ought to I delete the app?

For these second-guessing their period-tracking app, Ford says there is a threat vs. comfort calculation that is totally different for every consumer. It relies upon largely on the place you reside and what the legal guidelines are.

“If I lived in a state the place abortion was actively being criminalized, I might not use a interval tracker — that is for certain,” she says.

However for individuals who select to log their information on-line, there is likely to be some choices that are not as dangerous. Ford says that apps constructed with a nonprofit mannequin may supply extra privateness.

Hong says paid apps could possibly be higher as a result of they’re much less prone to observe customers, since they need not gather promoting information. Hong additionally suggested customers to learn Apple’s privateness vitamin labels, that are designed to point out customers how their information is utilized in less complicated phrases.

Apps that retailer information regionally are additionally preferable, Greer defined, as a result of when information is saved regionally, the consumer owns it — not the corporate.

If police are excited about information saved on a consumer’s system, they would want a warrant, which has a “a lot larger authorized bar” than a subpoena, Greer says. But when the info is within the cloud and owned by an organization, a subpoena can be essential to entry the info.

Ford says probably the most safe choice would possibly simply be probably the most old school: monitoring your cycle on paper.

“If you wish to be protected, use a paper calendar.”


Back To Top