Senate Democrats failed to advance a bill protecting abortion access nationwide : NPR


Senate Democrats tried, and failed, to advance laws to determine a federal legislation to guard abortion entry nationwide.


Right this moment, Senate Democrats tried and didn’t advance a invoice to require equal entry to abortion nationwide. All however one of many Senate’s 50 Democrats voted for it. That one Democrat was West Virginia Senator Joe Manchin, who sided with all of the Republicans in opposition to the invoice. Democrats have been responding to a just lately leaked Supreme Courtroom draft opinion that might overturn Roe v. Wade and would in the end permit states to ban or prohibit abortion entry. Now, the ultimate court docket resolution is predicted subsequent month.

And becoming a member of us now could be NPR congressional correspondent Susan Davis. Hey, Sue.


CHANG: OK. I imply, it was a on condition that Democrats did not have sufficient votes to advance an abortion invoice within the Senate. So what was the purpose of right this moment’s vote?

DAVIS: , actually, the one factor Democrats can do right here is attempt to create political strain towards Republicans going into the election. Senate Majority Chief Chuck Schumer stated as a lot this morning on the Senate flooring.


CHUCK SCHUMER: Tens of thousands and thousands of girls are watching what is going to occur to the rights they’ve relied on for many years. And all of us must reply for this vote for the remainder of our time in public workplace.

DAVIS: Democrats stay assured they’ve public opinion on their facet – most Individuals in polls say they do consider ladies ought to have some degree of entry to abortion procedures – however they’re primarily powerless to do something to cease the court docket in the event that they rule to overturn Roe, regardless of controlling Congress and the White Home. The realities of the 50-50 Senate haven’t modified. Democrats do not have the votes to vary the Senate filibuster guidelines to make it simpler to cross laws. And right this moment’s vote additionally proved they do not actually have a easy majority of help to cross the invoice, even when they did.

CHANG: Yeah. I imply, what about Manchin? I imply, hasn’t he stated that he does help codifying Roe v. Wade into federal legislation? However he voted towards the invoice right this moment. Why?

DAVIS: He additionally voted towards an analogous invoice again in February. Manchin helps some degree of primary abortion entry, however he is all the time been extra of a socially conservative Democrat, and he is extra supportive of restrictions round abortions – consider issues like obligatory ready durations or requiring ultrasounds earlier than an abortion might be carried out. He instructed reporters he feared that this invoice would go too far, that it will supersede states which have restrictions like that in place, and he did not help that. He needed extra of a pared down invoice.

CHANG: Effectively, what about two Republican ladies senators? I am speaking about Susan Collins of Maine and Lisa Murkowski of Alaska. I imply, they each brazenly help Roe v. Wade, however they voted towards the invoice right this moment. How did they clarify that?

DAVIS: They shared numerous those self same considerations as Manchin, however they’ve additionally launched competing laws that might additionally codify Roe, it simply would not go so far as the Democrats’ invoice to guard abortion rights. It might additionally do extra to guard individuals who have non secular or ethical opposition to abortion, and it’s drawing some degree of Democratic curiosity. Collins is speaking to senators like Manchin. One other senator, Tim Kaine is a Democrat from Virginia who has additionally had, a minimum of beforehand, some extra conservative views round abortion entry, definitely in comparison with extra liberal Democrats.

However on the identical time, the identical downside nonetheless exists. It is unlikely that they might get any further Republicans on board for his or her Republican invoice and extremely unlikely they’ll get a essential mass of Democrats on board for it both.

CHANG: Yeah. So if that’s the case, the place does this abortion debate on Capitol Hill go?

DAVIS: I imply, in Congress, it is frankly going nowhere, a minimum of not earlier than the election. One of many huge questions within the midterms is, how a lot of this influence have on voters? I imply, Democrats wish to consider that it’ll carry voters to the polls to vote for them, however it’s simply not clear but how voters are going to rank abortion in deciding how they’ll vote.

And, , Republicans stay closely favored to win management of the Home. And if that occurs, there will probably be zero likelihood of any laws to guard abortion rights within the subsequent Congress.

CHANG: That’s NPR congressional correspondent Susan Davis. Thanks, Sue.

DAVIS: You are welcome.

Copyright © 2022 NPR. All rights reserved. Go to our web site terms of use and permissions pages at for additional info.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by an NPR contractor. This textual content might not be in its closing type and could also be up to date or revised sooner or later. Accuracy and availability might fluctuate. The authoritative report of NPR’s programming is the audio report.


Back To Top